Italian Street Market
About This Spot
Stepping into Italian Street Market feels like unlocking a small doorway to an old-world Italian neighborhood right in the heart of Lynbrook. It’s a cozy, intimate spot where time seems to slow down just enough to let the aromas of fresh bread, cured meats, and aged cheeses envelop you in a quiet comfort. The pace is unhurried here, inviting visitors to linger a little while among shelves stocked with thoughtfully curated imports and housemade treats.
This is not your typical grocery store—it’s more of a neighborhood gathering place, a tiny treasure trove filled with rich flavors and simple pleasures. The market’s warmth comes not only from its carefully selected ingredients but also from the genuine friendliness of the people behind the counter, who welcome each guest like a familiar friend stopping by. You might find yourself drawn to the ready-made sandwiches near the register, or browsing for that elusive Italian specialty ingredient that grocery giants overlook.
The charm of Italian Street Market shines brightest in its layers of authentic human connection and culinary heritage. Whether you’re drawn by the promise of freshly baked focaccia or the sight of robust cheeses stacked high, there’s a feeling of sharing in something crafted with care—a calm corner of everyday joy wrapped in familiar traditions and flavors. It’s a place where the act of shopping becomes a quiet celebration of good food and genuine hospitality, making it easy to understand why visitors return time and again.
What’s Available Here
-
Wheelchair-accessible car park
-
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
-
Food
-
Quick visit
-
Credit cards
-
Debit cards
Location & Hours
| Monday | Closed | |
| Tuesday | Closed | |
| Wednesday | 10:00 AM - 05:00 PM | |
| Thursday | 10:00 AM - 05:00 PM | |
| Friday | 10:00 AM - 05:00 PM | |
| Saturday | 10:00 AM - 03:00 PM | |
|---|---|---|
| Sunday | 10:00 AM - 03:00 PM |
Louis Petruzzelli 11 Jan 2026
Great food..friendly..Definitely will go back when I'm in the area
Les Corrigan 24 Dec 2025
The Italian Street Market in Lynbrook is absolutely fantastic! The fresh pastries, homemade sauces, and authentic deli items make it feel like a slice of Italy right in New York. The staff are warm and welcoming, and every visit feels like a celebration. If you love great food and genuine Italian charm, this market is a must-visit!
A_Food_For_All 20 Nov 2025
This is a tiny little Italian market with delicious premade sandwiches. Vincenzo was so super sweet. I also got the olive and pepper salad. I got a huge chunk of Parmesan cheese. I will definitely be going back. They only take cash, which is totally fine by me just letting everyone know.
Cynthia Jameson 21 Oct 2025
The food from here is always delicious and fresh! They have a very good selection of meats and cheeses that are great quality and they have excellent breads. Great Italian imports are always stocked on their shelves! If you are also cooking/baking and the recipe calls for an Italian product that regular groceries stores don’t have, call or stop by this shop, because they will most likely have the ingredients you are looking for!!!
Jamie G 16 Oct 2025
Such a cute little shop in Lynbrook. Honestly, it was a review that lead me here and I wasn't disappointed. The variety of fresh breads is incredible. There are so many cheeses and dried meats to choose from. They do not, however, make sandwiches to order, but there are daily sandwiches that can be found by the register. Cash only.
Jec C. 10 Oct 2025
The shop is a small shop in the middle of a village in Italy. It's welcoming and felt homey. As soon as I walked in I was immediately was greeted by the owner. She is super nice very talkative cool person friendly and fancy. I bought the sandwich of the day. A lot of meats and fresh made mozzarella with sweet spicy peppers and dribbled with evoo. I will definitely go back for another sandwich of the day and to browse around. The shop is 100% legit.
Desert Sunshine 08 Oct 2025
Omgoodness YESSSSSS!This iItalian Street Market is absolute Gold. Beyond grateful for their menu. A MUST for anyone who loves a good Italian restaurant. Grab a Deeeeeeeelicious Sandwich. Highly recommend.Enjoy
J J 21 Sep 2025
Love this place. The sandwiches are always fresh and delicious. Great little place.Cash only though.